*Please note that while I was a licensed insurance agent for auto and home in the state of Virginia in 2008, it has been several years since I’ve used this knowledge. If you are in the process of purchasing auto insurance, please make sure to double check all information with your insurance provider. Coverage requirements also vary widely from company to company and definitely from state to state.
Oh, and Liberty Mutual is not sponsoring this post. I just liked the commercial and it illustrated a few types of coverage pretty well.*
This is Mona.
I LOVE Mona. Seriously, I’m not generally too attached to too many things, but I am emotionally attached to my car.
Mona and I have been on several amazing adventures. Mona was there when I decided on a whim that I was moving to San Francisco. So I piled up everything I owned and drove across the country.
Mona was also there when I stopped at my best friend’s house in Las Vegas and we decided to go on a road trip into the desert that literally led up off the road and into the middle of the desert, where there did not appear to be any sort of road to find the abandoned art city of Rhyolite.
We also got yelled at by the military that we were too close to Area 51 when we went looking for it.
Mona and I also headed back north a year later when it made no sense to pay San Francisco rent because I was living on a cruise ship. We saw Mt. Rushmore and the Corn Palace together.
Then Mona got me all over the East coast to catch up with all of my friends during my different cruise ship vacations.
Most recently, Mona traversed all of America again and survived each week’s train yard (which is no small feat – train yards are generally pretty horrible). Most of the time I drove her, but several times she got my friends from point A to point B so I could relax on the train and they could go see family or friends.
But now I live in New York City and it is not a Mona friendly place. I go to my parents in New Jersey like every weekend and I drive her then, but is that really worth $100 a month?
I didn’t think so, so I called my insurance company to see if we could put storage insurance on her instead.
When I was in grad school, I worked for Nationwide Insurance in Virginia and there you’re able to put insurance on your vehicle that pretty much keeps you covered if a tree falls through your garage, since you’re no longer covered by collision or liability or any other sort of insurance. It was about $5 a month circa 2008.
I figured I’d do the same thing and just drive one of my parent’s cars if I needed to go grab something, but when I talked with the good people of New Jersey, I learned that this is not an option here. You have to have liability here. Which brought my car insurance down to only $800. Seriously? ONLY? There’s barely any point in switching it then!
So I went back and forth on the matter in my head for several weeks and finally decided I was just going to reinsure my car like usual when the bill arrived this week. I mostly decided that because I’m actually able to afford it right now.
It’s both very fortunate and very frustrating that I seem to get hit by bills when I’m a little bit ahead financially. I feel like I never manage to get really ahead because of it, but on the flip side I’m very grateful I’m always able to get them paid.
Ever wonder what some of those terms on your auto policy mean?
Comprehensive Coverage – this means that some unfortunate thing has happened to your car other than a collision (which is why it is sometimes called “other than collision coverage”). That commercial with the guy who drops an air conditioner out of his window and onto a car? Well, hopefully that car owner had comprehensive. An angry squirrel shatters your windshield with an acorn? Hopefully you have comprehensive. It also covers you if your car is stolen or vandalized.
Most new cars have comprehensive coverage on them (it’s a requirement if you’re leasing the car). If you’re driving a clunker where the deductible costs more than your car, that’s when you can start to think about taking it off your policy.
Collision Coverage – this is another coverage you may consider dropping once the value of your car considerably depreciates.
Collision coverage is exactly what it sounds like, it covers you if you hit another vehicle or object. In that commercial, it’s what the gentlemen who drives into the garage hopefully has. For a new car, collision coverage makes a lot of sense. My car is currently worth $6,400 based on Kelly’s Blue Book and I still think it’s worth it. I bought my first car, a 1993 Mazda MX-3 for about $1,800 and it was never worth it to me back then.
Liability Insurance – all but 3 states require you to at least have liability insurance. California and Wisconsin will waive this requirement if you can provide “proof of financial responsibility.” This usually involves placing a very large deposit with the DMV (between $30,000-$60,000, depending on the state). New Hampshire does not require any proof of financial responsibility.
Liability insurance protects your from lawsuits related to any car accident up to the amount of coverage you’ve chosen.
Personal Injury Protection (PIP) Coverage – this coverage is for medical bills and lost wages sustained as the result of an accident. It can also be used to cover funeral expenses. In No-Fault states (Delaware, Florida, Hawaii, Kansas, Kentucky, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, New Jersey, New York, North Dakota, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Texas, Utah and D.C.), there is a minimum amount of coverage required and then you can sign a waiver to opt out of higher coverage.
Shouldn’t insurance just cover that? Well, yeah. It sort of does. But you have to figure out whose fault the accident was, so that their insurance company pays for what happened. That could involve years of legal battles and all the accompanying fees. PIP insurance means that your medical bills are just paid (up to the coverage limit), regardless of whose fault the accident was. Unfortunately, it also really limits your ability to take a case to court, if you felt that was necessary.
If you have excellent health insurance, it’s usually worth looking into if they cover auto accidents. If you can supply documents proving they do to your auto insurance company, they will often lower or waive the PIP requirement. PIP is often a fairly expensive aspect of your insurance premium, so this can save you a good deal of money over time.
Uninsured Motorist Coverage – It could be just me, but this one irritates me a little. It shouldn’t be my job to pay for the idiots who just didn’t get insurance, especially since that’s illegal every except New Hampshire. Nonetheless, that’s pretty much what this premium covers.
If you’re hit by someone who is not carrying insurance and is broke, you can’t squeeze water from a stone. Granted, you can sue and garnish the stone’s wages for the rest of their life, but that’s not going to get you a new car to get to work next week. Uninsured Motorist coverage will. It will also help cover medical bills (especially if you don’t have PIP coverage). Uninsured Motorist coverage is often paired with Underinsured Motorist coverage, which means exactly what it says – the person at fault did not have enough insurance coverage to cover what occurred and cannot afford to pay for the damages.
This coverage also covers hit and runs, since you’d be unable to find the at fault party in those situations.
Fun Fact: When I was working as an insurance agent, a person once called to try to cover their motorized wheelchair on their auto insurance policy. Since I was new, that call was forwarded right onto my supervisor after a few flabbergasted minutes together trying to figure out how to make that request work in our obnoxious, super specific computer system. I imagine it actually became a floater on her homeowner’s policy… but I sure didn’t know that back then.
Additionally, I made a man very angry when I wouldn’t insure his parade float. Life in a call center… nothing will make you get your act together quicker to GTFO that kind of job.
Wondering where the best and worst car insurance premiums can be found?
Top 5 Highest Average Car Insurance Premiums:
- 5. Rhode Island – $2,020
- 4. Washington, D.C. – $2,127
- 3. Georgia – $2,201
- 2. West Virginia – $2,518
- 1. Michigan – $2,551
Top 5 Lowest Car Insurance Premiums:
- 4. Idaho – $1,053
- 3. New Hampshire – $983
- 2. Maine – $964
- 1. Ohio – $926
Check out the whole list here and see where your state ranks.
Keep in mind, those are just averages, and they’re of the whole state. Certain cities and urban areas have significantly higher average. I’m lucky enough to live right next to the 4th most expensive city for car insurance in America – Newark, NJ – where the average premium is $3,525.43. Aside from the fact that people from New Jersey all drive like psychopaths (although not nearly as crazy as people from New York and Pennsylvania. Has anyone else noticed it’s always the states next to you that drive the craziest and cause the most rage when you see their license plates? It’s never you), Newark is also a lovely hotbed of crime and our winters do suck. We don’t even get a ton of pretty snow, it’s all ice and then fishtail enabling slush.
While I totally believe that is the average for Newark, my own premium is $1,119.65, which is a reminder that you should always shop around for your auto coverage. And one thing I definitely did learn from my days with an insurance agency, you will almost always save more by bundling all your insurance needs with one company. That’s when the discounts really start to kick in!
Anyone else ready to go back to the horse and buggy days after trying to make sense of their insurance premiums?